19 Comments

Oh man, this was such a throwback. I haven't read one of these in so long! Definitely need to get my hands on some more Creepy comics. Come to think of it, I see these at my local antique shops all the time!

Expand full comment
author

I hadn’t thought about trawling antique shops. That’s actually a great idea. I wonder if they would be cheaper or more expensive there.

Expand full comment

I want to say they would be cheaper but it depends on the shop. Some that we have gone to charge outrageous prices. I just picked up a copy of Startling Stories and it was around $25. It was well worth it!

Expand full comment

I wish I would come across these when I was a kid. However, my connection with Conan (both the paperbacks and the magazine). Thank the maker for family that see that light in your eye and help guide you.

Expand full comment
author

You should just thank the Comics Code Authority that you didn't come across these because they would have distracted you from your studies and you'd be in an entirely different career now.

Expand full comment

I hope you mean a career as a serial killer, cult leader, or mad scientist. Sometime I miss what could have been.

Expand full comment
author

Mad scientist. Mad professor. Tomato. Tomahto.

Expand full comment

I didn't get into Creepy until my late twenties when my husband introduced me. It felt like coming home!

Expand full comment
author

I read them hit or miss throughout childhood because I was dependent on adults to buy them and it was entirely luck-of-the-draw on whether I'd be at the store when an issue I hadn't already read hit the newsstand.

As an adult, I grabbed all of the collected editions on Comixology back when it still existed. They are still available on Kindle. If you're missing any copies you should look them up. They've collected multiple issues into single volumes so it's not super expensive to buy every book. Whether you should buy every issue or not is a matter of judgement, but I definitely think everyone should read at least the first two volumes because they were edited almost exclusively by Archie Goodwin and he's really the guy who made these books sing.

Expand full comment

My husband has a few if the volumes I think

Expand full comment
Nov 27, 2023Liked by John Ward

This was a fun read, John. I'd never heard of Creepy and was never into comics as a kid, but I 100% loved thumbing through magazines like Highlights and American Girl that that found ways to weave in both educational and entertainment stuff.

The rubber fly ad reminded me of begging my mom to let me buy Sea-Monkeys from a magazine ad which turned out to be the brine shrimp living and available for free at the boat docks in Salt Lake City where I lived. Ha!

Expand full comment
author

Yeah... a lot of those old ads were for products of dubious quality. Still a lot of fun to read though.

Expand full comment

What a wonderful discovery! Not only are the comics scary, suspenseful, but also insightful!

Expand full comment

These look so fun! Next time I go to my local comic store I'll have to keep an eye out on these and see if I can snag one.

Expand full comment
author

You really should. You might have to ask one of the employees for where they are though. Most stores keep comics that are this old filed away in long boxes so it's not the type of thing you're going to see sitting on a shelf. But, they are definitely worth digging out. They had so many great artists and writers working on the series. I think you'll enjoy them.

Expand full comment

Big Creepshow vibe

Expand full comment
author

Yeah. Creepshow was inspired by these and other horror comics that were put out at the same time. Stephen King and George Romero wanted to create a nostalgic callback to the comics and horror stories that they'd enjoyed when they were younger and that's how Creepshow came about.

Expand full comment

Ctrl-F "archie goodwin" found

Expand full comment
author

Anyone who calls out Archie Goodwin knows what's up. He was the magic sauce behind Creepy and every other thing he edited. His work deserves an entire post dedicated exclusively to him.

Expand full comment